The Selectorate theory and Syrian regime survival.

 

Demand is growing for US involvement in Syria but not all rebellions are created equal. There is no indication that the Assad leadership will abide to any power sharing transition like what was observed in Tunisia or Egypt. Not only is Assad’s party stubbornly clinging to power, Syria stands apart from other movements of the Arab spring for its level of conflict. The violence taking place in Syria is both qualitatively and quantitatively different. It is estimated that approximate 11 percent of Syria has died, some of which have occurred through chemical attacks.

There are a host of historical and cultural reasons why some regimes do not gracefully transition to power. Outside powers, such as Iran and Russia, are aggravating the situation and there is a precedent in Syria of taking a heavy hand towards rebellions. But little discussion has been made of how the existing Syrian political economy exacerbates the length and amount of conflict being observed. I suggest that the reason why Syria is such as violent mess is because of the incentives of those in power to remain loyal to the leadership. I draw on insights produced by the selectorate theory which argues that regime loyalty and the lengths they will go to retain power are shaped by two institutions, the winning coalition and the selectorate.

For the uninitiated, the selectorate model argues two institutions shape regime stability. The selectorate is the subset of residents that have a genuine opportunity to select state leadership. Selectorate membership is derived from state specific institutional characteristics such as lineage, wealth, or legal qualifications. In democratic regimes, especially those commonly referred to as western, the selectorate is generally all citizens over the age of 18. The size of the selectorate in authoritarian or military regimes is usually more narrow and generally consists of a small coalition of elites. The winning coalition is that subset of the selectorate that abides by state specific institutional conditions to confer political authority over the residents of the state. Political candidates of any style of regime must by definition form their winning coalition of supporters from the selectorate. This is done through public policy which can be allocated to either private or public goods. What shapes the allocation of state resources is the pressure of a challenger. If an incumbent fails to offer members of the winning coalition the best public policy bundle, a challenger will be able to persuade members of the winning coalition to defect. Holding utility constant, it is assumed that members of the selectorate would prefer to receive private goods to public goods. In general, the larger the wining coalition, the more incentive leadership has to offer public policy in the form of public goods. This takes the form of efficient institutions, the impartial rule of law, and transparent governing. When the winning coalition is small, there is an incentive to offer public policy to the winning coalition in the form of private goods. This includes state licenses, income from rent seeking, and other forms of corruption.

The relationship is made clear through an example. Let R be the total amount of income produced in a state where R= $1,000. If W is the size of the winning coalition and all of the state resources are allocated towards private goods, then $1,000/W decreases as W increases. That is, $1,000/2 > $1,000/4, 1,000/4 > $1,000/6, and so forth. Public goods, however, are not discriminatory and their consumption by one individual does not preclude consumption by others. It is assumed that the preference for public goods are uniformly distributed in the winning coalition so that all members of the winning coalition benefit evenly from their production. Unlike private goods, the size of the wining coalition does not effect the consumption of public goods. If R=$1,000 and the public good gives each member of the winning coalition the equivalent of $30 worth of utility, then for a state with a winning coalition of 40 members, public goods will be produced because $1,000/40=$25 per member, which is less than $30. If the winning coalition consists of 20 members, then $1,000/20 = $50 and private goods will be produced because $50>$30. The more members in a winning coalition, the less state resources are available to be distributed among those in that coalition. For those interested I provide this more formally as an addendeum.

The theory has a host of interesting applications including the democratic peace theory (winning a war is treated as a public good so democracies will divert a large amount of resources towards winning them) to how leadership responds to natural disasters.

In addition to shaping what sort of public policy state leadership will offer, the selectorate and winning coalition explain regime loyalty. The amount of loyalty is proxied by the ratio of the winning collation to the selectorate, or W/S. If W/S is large, the loyalty of those in W will be low because if W is large or S is small then the probability of being included in the next coalition is high. If W is small and S large than the probability of being in the next coalition is low. Let W = 300 and S = 2,000,000 then the probability of being in the next coalition is 300/2,000,000 or 0.0015. This is a very rough approximation of North Korea. If W = 65,000,000 and S = 150,000,000 then the probability of being in the next coalition is 65,000,000/150,000,000 or 0.43. This is a very rough approximation of the United States.

A small winning coalition with a large selectorate induces loyalty as public policy is largely defined by private consumption and the fact that a member of the winning coalition is easily replaced. A member of W is less valuable to the challenger when W/S is small. The probability of being in the next winning coalition is too small and the costs are too great to expect any orderly regime change. Unfortunately for American options in Syria, a large selectorate and a small winning coalition is what Syria has. The ratio W/S explains a good amount of why Syria is approaching its 5th year and why the violence only seems to being increasing. Those in the winning coalition have demonstrated that they will go to great lengths to retain power including the use of chemical weapons against civilians. This means that the Assad regime will not go quietly as other regimes such as Egypt which has about half the size of a selectorate as Syria does. As I’ve wrote before on this blog, a sober assessment of American priorities should be taken prior to taking initiatives towards involving itself in Syria. Those advocating that “Assad most go” needs to mindful of the existing political economy in Syria and what that means for a power transition. After 5 years of civil war, it’s obvious that a regime change will not occur with a light footprint strategy. If the United States wants a power transition, it needs to fully commit because the Baathist party of Syria has far too much at stake to entertain any minor compromise of its political power.

 

Appendix.

Below is a simplified version of the selectorate theory. I’m still new to wordpress so if someone has a better way of writing equations let me know, but I was forced to cut and paste using my MAC’s screen shot feature.

I reduced the model to only demonstrating the relevant parts for the above discussion. The model is more involved and elaborate than presented here, almost to the point of sacrificing parsimony for granularity. For the interested reader, I highly recommend the following book. It is the most comprehensive treatment of the Selectorate Theory to date and has deeply shaped my thinking on foreign policy.

State leadership will attempt to maximize discretionary income, which is the difference between total state revenue and public policy.

 

screen-shot-2016-10-31-at-3-54-18-pm

Total state revenue explicitly modeled takes a common form. It is assumed that the tax rate is applied evenly across all residents. I treat as exogenous.

screen-shot-2016-10-31-at-3-56-37-pm

Public policy offered by the incumbent is a bundle of public and private goods so that

screen-shot-2016-10-31-at-3-57-39-pm

Public policy of the incumbent can be modeled explicitly as

screen-shot-2016-10-31-at-3-58-08-pm

It is assumed that private goods are distributed evenly to the winning coalition which allows W to serve as a proxy price for private goods. If M­g is the amount of an incumbents public policy allocated towards private goods, then each member of W receives Mg/W share. If the winning coalition increases, so does the overall cost of providing private goods. If the winning coalition decreases, so does the overall cost of providing private goods.

The objective function of the incumbent fully assembled and explicitly stated is below.

screen-shot-2016-10-31-at-3-58-38-pm

 

Leadership will choose to maximize If a Markov Perfect Equilibria is assumed, then holds due to the challenger constraint. That is, to prevent defection from his winning coalition, the incumbent was required to offer a bundle of private and pubic goods in the previous round that provided at a minimum the same amount of utility to the least affiliated member of his coalition that a challenger did. The model assumes that each member of the selectorate has a level of affinity for political leadership that is based on cultural and ideological connections. The full set of affinities for those in W can be linearly ordered based on the strength of affinity for leadership. If is affinity then the set of all affinities of those in the selectorate can be arranged where 0< < 1. Affinity for leadership is treated as a residual of support after utility from public policy is consumed. This will allow for any stalemates between incumbent and challenger to be resolved if utility derived from public policy is the same between incumbent and challenger. That is, a member of the selectorate will arrive at their choice of leadership based firstly on utility derived from the combination of private and public goods offered by leadership. Affinity for leadership will only decide support of leadership if public policies offered by candidates are the same. A political rival will attempt to persuade the member in the incumbents winning coalition with the lowest affinity (or lowest affinity member (LAM)) to defect by offering a public policy that offers them more utility than the incumbent. An incumbent only need to match this utility as he benefits from what is described as the ‘incumbency advantage’. This is the advantage enjoyed by incumbents when the utility offered from the challenger is discounted by the fact that a challenger must first attain power and the utility offered by someone not in leadership is uncertain. To defect from the winning coalition would result in a forfeiture of all utility offered by the leadership’s public policy.

The constraint is that the incumbent must match the best public policy bundle of any challenger.

screen-shot-2016-10-31-at-6-39-51-pm

screen-shot-2016-10-31-at-4-00-16-pm

screen-shot-2016-10-31-at-4-00-46-pm

 

screen-shot-2016-10-31-at-6-34-20-pm

0 Replies to “The Selectorate theory and Syrian regime survival.”

  1. my campus
    Mint: Money Manager, Bills, Credit Score & Budgeting, personal credit.Personal credit
    How do you measure up? The average credit score for Mint users is 705 (national avg. is 673*). Check yours for free in Mint. How do you measure up? The average credit score for Mint users is 705 (national avg. is 673*). Check yours for free in Mint. How do you measure up? The average credit score for Mint users is 705 (national avg. is 673*). Check yours for free in Mint. Budgets? You betcha Easily create budgets, and see our suggestions based on your spending. Bills? Done Track and pay bills like never before. Get alerts and schedule payments …
    The post Mint: Money Manager, Bills, Credit Score & Budgeting, personal credit.Personal credit appeared first on Credit.

    [url=http://free.remmont.com]Credits News[/url]
    [url=http://reply.remmont.com/madura-english-sinhala-dictionary-free-download-and-software-reviews-cnet-reply-in-spanish/]madura online sinhala english dictionary[/url]
    [url=http://game.remmont.com/gamez-eoin-gamez-games-free-free/]eoin gamez happy wheels[/url]
    [url=http://remmont.com/toad-for-sql-server-freeware-free-download-and-software-reviews-cnet-toad-for-sql-server-freeware-free-toad-for-sql-server-freeware-downloads-download-toad-for-sql-server-freew/]toad sql server[/url]
    [url=http://remmont.com/no-deposit-car-insurance-find-low-deposits-on-car-cover/]deposit[/url]
    [url=http://reply.remmont.com/madura-english-sinhala-dictionary-free-download-and-software-reviews-cnet-thank-you-for-your-reply-email/]madura dictionary[/url]

    [b]TOP 250 FREE DOFOLLOW SITE LINK LIST

    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message795928/?result=reply#message795928
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798761/
    http://forum.zenstudios.com/member.php?1705350-TRAVELMuh
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12768/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message745344/
    http://rest-n-buy.ru/communication/forum/messages/forum3/topic11/message16260/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message775370/?result=reply#message775370
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message784444/?result=reply#message784444
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message776995/?result=reply#message776995
    http://mobsigames.ru/battle-bay-android/?unapproved=5232&moderation-hash=952fc18633c215cf4a05d4e3e23d6c7d#comment-5232
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message762033/?result=reply#message762033
    http://loadinfo.ru/forum/topic_2/13919#post-926169/
    http://forum.remmont.com/us-state-employees-left-without-a-salary-prepared-gifts/#comment/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message783155/?result=reply#message783155
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12787/
    http://mxo.hardlinedreams.com/forum/member.php?action=profile&uid=104236
    http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12790/
    http://mama-koroleva.ru/forum/13-33894-29#2705552
    http://www.floridasports.club/wp-admin/edit.php?post_title=Details%3A+China+Business+Fresh+News.+http%3A%2F%2Freal-estate.nef2.com&post_name=NEF2mafe&mm=10&jj=24&aa=2018&hh=03&mn=NEF2mafe&ss=49&post_category%5B%5D=0&tax_input%5Bpost_tag%5D=%5BIMG%5Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fremmont.com%2Fdemotivator%2F2326.jpg+border%3D10+height%3D240+width%3D240%5B%2FIMG%5D+%5Bb%5DPolitics+of+Russia+We+n+we+publish+all+of+them+fresh+and+advanced+facts+World%2C+analytics+experts.+All+evil+in+the+world+is+created+with+the+quiet+tacit+consent+of+the+indifferent.+No+one+provides+us+with+incentives.+We+are+People.+We+are+building+a+civil+society.+The+people+are+the+bearer+of+sovereignty+and+the+only+source+of+power.+No+one+can+usurp+power.+Useful+topics+-+NATO+%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.real-estate.nef2.com%5DUganda+Business%5B%2Furl%5D+%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fgame.remmont.com%2Fgamez-eoin-gamez-games-free-free%2F%5D+eoin+gamez+%5B%2Furl%5D%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Freply.remmont.com%2Furban-dictionary-cheers-big-ears-dictionary-free%2F%5D+cheers+big+ears+same+goes+big+nose+%5B%2Furl%5D+%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fbusiness.nef2.com%2Fva-once-student-login-page-u-reservist-army-reserve-naval-reserve-air-force-reserve-marine-corps-reserve-coast-guard-reserve-army-national-reserve-air-national-reserve-va%2F%5D+va+once+school+login+%5B%2Furl%5D%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fnef2.com%2Fnorth-carolina-real-estate-school-nc-real-estate-courses-tampa-bay-real-estate%2F%5D+jy+monk+real+estate+training+center+%5B%2Furl%5D+%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fpharma.nef6.com%2F2018%2F07%2F14%2Faurobindo-pharma-share-price-pharma-tech-pharma-tech-2%2F%5D+aurobindo+share+price+%5B%2Furl%5D&_status=pending&_inline_edit=0de2b9c4ae&post_view=list&screen=edit-post&comment_status=closed&ping_status=closed&_status=draft&post_format=image&bulk_edit=Update&post_view=list&screen=edit-post
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message774951/?result=reply#message774951
    http://slubovyu.com/index/8-4466
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message780778/?result=reply#message780778
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message795034/?result=reply#message795034
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message737996/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message784568/?result=reply#message784568
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic181921/message775849/?sessid=f79706a509e05d2626c4dc0dd66290ed&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798767/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message795234/?result=reply#message795234
    http://forum.remmont.com/israel-syria-iran-maybe-its-easier-to-declare-war/#comment/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message782376/?result=reply#message782376
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799383/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic181812/message774616/?sessid=463e27069f40cebae41c462a8c0a55de&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
    http://forum.autorubik.sk/forums/tema/facts-sacramento-business-current-news-http-travels-remmont-com/
    http://forum.remmont.com/tag/iraqi-popular-mobilization-units-artillery-pounds-isis-positions-in-eastern-syria/#comment/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message783031/?result=reply#message783031
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message784654/?result=reply#message784654
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799055/
    http://xnonqu75bcvap11j.lohasmassage.com/viewthread.php?tid=1128&extra=
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12721#comment-2990/
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799439/
    http://xn--z-6a3mdacaaa76pc56n4baeqd01a.hz-nano.com/viewthread.php?tid=72007&extra=
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message775279/?result=reply#message775279
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message781365/?result=reply#message781365
    http://iw-wi.ru/forum/showthread.php?28677-Analytics-Eritrea-Finance-Current-News-remmont-com&p=104705#post104705
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic183554/message783241/?sessid=bdb08c83193ee0870c62c129c679c548&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
    http://bbs.teledu.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=197055
    http://nytva.org/memberlist.php?mode=searchuser&sd=d&sk=l
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799283/
    http://www.orcasound.com/2004/04/28/2002latingrammynominees/?unapproved=154815&moderation-hash=556132d50d71da4b561d5602cfa53950#comment-154815
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799077/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message777878/?result=reply#message777878
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic183237/message780698/?sessid=8ec613fde60b57d072164fc3d5a3a899&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message737982/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message777881/?result=reply#message777881
    http://invasion.tap4fun.com/forum/member.php?471727-REMONTrix
    http://forum.remmont.com/tag/the-saker-blogviewthe-saker-archive-the-russian-pension-chickens-are-coming-home-to-roost/#comment/
    http://forum.remmont.com/china-has-exposed-us-cheating-worldwide/#comment/
    http://school108perm.ucoz.ru/index/8-46985
    http://ngoinhachung.net/diendan/15-1/sinh-vien-thao-luan.htm/baiviet/baiviet/diendan/baiviet/details-savings-news-current-news-remmont-com-2017264-1-1.html
    http://russianculturalcenterinalaska.com/index.php?subaction=userinfo&user=INSURANCEvem
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message775096/?result=reply#message775096
    http://aidasdb.org/microblogs/inauguaration-of-migrant-desk/?unapproved=8516&moderation-hash=9bc5d63a6cf6c8b3e9e8a2bd2264aecf#comment-8516
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798591/
    http://www.toolandfab.com/members/133210-REMONTKa
    http://goodyblythe.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=27889
    http://www.bizweb.ru/topic/293-kak-sozdat-svoj-sajt/page-3#entry169216/
    http://tianzhuso.gotoip55.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=364295
    http://kvadratremont.ru/forum/messages/forum/8/message13531/49-pochemu-otkleivayutsya-oboi?result=reply#message13531
    http://www.dms.mn/forums/topic/tfl-store-update-041310-httpbahamas-remmont-com/
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799039/
    http://orshagorodmoy.info/forum/47-284-252#54177
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12753#comment-5529/
    http://bong88agent.com/forum/profile.php?id=235946
    http://oldmfl-forum.angelovo-sport.ru/member.php?u=290536
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798580/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message755227/?result=reply#message755227
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message755395/?result=reply#message755395
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message731474/
    http://mini-koparka.pl/katalog-szukaj-katalogu/?unapproved=11904&moderation-hash=a179964967dfb6504755b33f7971d6d8#comment-11904
    http://216.250.104.34/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=11037&extra=
    http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12724/4698/
    http://snachina.com/snachina/space-uid-15253.html
    http://dog-32.ru/index/8-39145
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message755823/?result=reply#message755823
    http://www.bizweb.ru/topic/293-kak-sozdat-svoj-sajt/page-2#entry83349/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message773018/?result=reply#message773018
    http://hepev.com/kendi-terrariumunuzu-kendiniz-yapin-11840/?unapproved=6599&moderation-hash=69476d1af62df86a9a5acd69b4aee417#comment-6599
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799166/
    http://moneyhaven.org/B_B/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=97
    http://intruder.superbossgames.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=41902
    http://www.bizweb.ru/topic/3807-chto-prodavat-na-rynke/page-2#entry89391/
    http://www.bizweb.ru/topic/15977-suvenirnaia-produktciia-optom-i-pod-zakaz/page-2/
    http://bbs.kangcare.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=30693
    http://80baicai.biz/home.php?mod=space&uid=88923
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12721#comment-3679/
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798730/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message771773/?result=reply#message771773
    http://esportshornets.de/phpBB-3.0.11-deutsch/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=19&t=7355
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message756146/?result=reply#message756146
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798984/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message784620/?result=reply#message784620
    http://kvadratremont.ru/forum/messages/forum/8/message13501/49-pochemu-otkleivayutsya-oboi?result=reply#message13501
    http://www.s0931.net/toa/home.php?mod=space&uid=59174
    http://www.cryptoworldjournal.com/crypto-economics/?unapproved=10932&moderation-hash=8e297e7de585304dc4a16ccb9bec47f8#comment-10932
    http://laboruniontv.org/bernie-sanders-calls-for-a-global-progressive-movement/#comment-417402/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message777083/?result=reply#message777083
    http://ymygl.com.cn/bbs/home.php?mod=space&uid=123231
    http://twinsengineeringgreatness.com/blog/chrisluizzi/good-snack?page=5#comment-102534
    http://virtualizate.net/2014/03/25/t-mobile-invita-liberarse-de-los-contratos-y-ofrece-hasta-650-por-linea/?unapproved=57376&moderation-hash=06f0fb3555696bd1444835b77ace6988#comment-57376
    http://natalia-tur.ru/index/8-62732
    http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12724/3229/
    http://mycomplexissue.co.za/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=111059
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/11834#comment-3455/
    albuquerque.remmont.com
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message772725/?result=reply#message772725
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798835/
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message771906/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic181948/message776133/?sessid=83242755e718b566d27e5f2e58ba4b05&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
    http://dburn.ru/users/REMONTPoef
    http://www.vespa-classic-club-geneve.ch/forum/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=447096
    http://pravo.r1v.ru/index/8-20445
    http://study.xrkky.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=13076
    http://blog.jll.eu/retail/london-the-worlds-ultimate-retail-destination/?unapproved=17583&moderation-hash=ae59603bc7f5aefb1653ae3187166812#comment-17583
    http://www.simplypets.com/portuguese-water-dogs-breeders/?unapproved=3828&moderation-hash=0f1160c0d716803b9df5b3b5fa848d30#comment-3828
    http://blog.redtube.com/2011/04/pornstar-katie-morgan-is-back-on-the-blog/dsc_0229/comment-page-4/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message762152/?result=reply#message762152
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message775314/?result=reply#message775314
    http://www.baicai-home.com/bbs/home.php?mod=space&uid=42473
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message740005/?result=reply#message740005
    montana.remmont.com
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message780708/?result=reply#message780708
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message778664/?result=reply#message778664
    http://eternium2.net/board/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=189369
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message774476/?result=reply#message774476
    http://kvadratremont.ru/forum/messages/forum/8/message13511/49-pochemu-otkleivayutsya-oboi?result=reply#message13511
    http://bbs.aimcenter.cn/space-uid-15686.html
    http://trailertips.com/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=1170
    http://forum.remmont.com/are-the-us-ready-to-lose-its-fleet-in-the-arctic/#comment/
    http://kvadratremont.ru/forum/messages/forum/8/message13567/49-pochemu-otkleivayutsya-oboi?result=reply#message13567
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message752827/?result=reply#message752827
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12590/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message779697/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message737245/
    http://kna-gimc.ucoz.ru/forum/25-25-3#1904
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message782069/?result=reply#message782069
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message782984/?result=reply#message782984
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798931/
    http://laboruniontv.org/can-we-live-forever/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message773716/?result=reply#message773716
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message795766/?result=reply#message795766
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message736963/
    http://laboruniontv.org/can-we-live-forever/#comment-395484/
    http://fan.fc-anji.ru/blogs/blog/guest/13842.html
    http://forum.remmont.com/us-blows-up-inf-another-move-towards-downfall/#comment/
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799270/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message780882/?result=reply#message780882
    http://ww.mamokazje.pl/okazja/9996/march-2017-discus-list-at-caf-breeding-pairs-local-raised#comment-25891/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message756435/?result=reply#message756435
    http://protectwhatisprecious.com/community/main-forum/thunder-vs-bulls-preview-and-gamethread-okc-requires-upon-somewhat-having-difficulties-chicago/paged/66/#post-19220/
    http://quotesmpire.com/topic/country/country-quotes/?unapproved=20833&moderation-hash=7756328ef303568923b6e18008f65277#comment-20833
    http://www.spelsberg-rus.com/goods.php?id=20013
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message776236/?result=reply#message776236
    http://xak-css.3dn.ru/index/8-28447
    http://citytur.ucoz.ru/index/8-27062
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message739900/
    http://portalmodowy.pl/5-popularnych-metod-na-wlosy-we-fryzjerstwie/?unapproved=1795&moderation-hash=6eaac7671ff70f357762a9070be0027f#comment-1795
    http://tiny-footprint.org/forum/topic/news-income-news-advanced-news-remmont-com/
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12789#comment-5745/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic181567/message773216/?sessid=6feebc51f030fea164574d45cd7a3147&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
    http://www.school2novoorsk.ru/index/8-16403
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798920/
    http://www.caveda31.com/blog/2017/01/30/pisos-de-lujo-junto-al-casco-historico-parque-de-la-rodriga/?unapproved=7&moderation-hash=8c6702d921094f90de8e630dfe609d25#comment-7
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799414/
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12787#comment-5672/
    http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12578/4076/
    http://97119.org/viewthread.php?tid=1835&pid=283081&page=329&extra=#pid283081
    http://larrygoins.com/the-charlotte-shake/?unapproved=1508&moderation-hash=3c251bcf3985ab98a6deb250c688db0d#comment-1508
    http://piwniczkamemow.pl/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message773888/?result=reply#message773888
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic183229/message780677/?sessid=1f7dcb21ba7907026fbf28a6ea724bcc&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
    http://nt1750.net/forum/home.php?mod=space&uid=36741
    http://ksusha.spb.ru/forum/thread59760-1.html#93238
    http://softnews.3dn.ru/
    http://forum.remmont.com/forum/rental/
    http://www.assignmenthelpreviews.com/member.php?action=profile&uid=400369
    http://kvadratremont.ru/forum/messages/forum/8/message13517/49-pochemu-otkleivayutsya-oboi?result=reply#message13517
    http://xn--jekv69lfrab734k859c.tailien.com/post.php?action=reply&fid=2&tid=1377012
    http://greypanel.stk-servers.ru/forum/topic?id=4939
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message780234/?result=reply#message780234
    http://valeur-dachat.fr/valgorect-avis-amazon-forum-france/?unapproved=328169&moderation-hash=3e70a6c948b55d0465a7fe6465a42605#comment-328169
    http://www.failodrom.ru/forum/27-109-1#25572/
    http://savedelete.com/software/pinnacle-studio-review/191217/?unapproved=903810&moderation-hash=1dee36c403b1369c927b0942f3f14d01&bs-comment-added=1#comment-903810
    louisville.remmont.com
    http://www.thetimepass.com/hollywood/disneys-aladdin-speechless-special-look/?unapproved=2314&moderation-hash=4bb0459ef9e27dc8dea6393d1d34f637#comment-2314
    http://androit.altervista.org/blog/app/#comment-81985
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message750238/?result=reply#message750238
    http://avsu88.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=1336
    http://xianlaiju.com/space-uid-1617651.html
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message795257/?result=reply#message795257
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message756440/?result=reply#message756440
    http://blog.nasm.org/sports-performance/hiit-hvit-viit-know-differences/?unapproved=109287&moderation-hash=91c170a7d42f2d6904e908e4fe7d8105#comment-109287
    http://zakon.zsperm.ru/forum/messages/forum1/topic3/message13/
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798837/
    http://nzk.funbbs.me/viewthread.php?tid=8394&extra=
    http://www.sirspa.com/forum/showthread.php?tid=149365
    http://uc.infinix.club/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1280369
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message755224/?result=reply#message755224
    http://carderx.com/showthread.php?358-no-login-dating-sites&p=3203&posted=1#post3203
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12842/
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12787#comment-5683/
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798729/
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12787#comment-5680/
    http://www.boomlive.in/facebook-removes-fake-news-page-postcard-for-copyright-violations/?unapproved=6685&moderation-hash=c4b734460528540e40e58e4ab06fa5e2#comment-6685
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12724#comment-5746/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message783046/?result=reply#message783046
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message775937/?result=reply#message775937
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message775331/?result=reply#message775331
    http://dailyuganda.com/node/12823#comment-5952/
    http://cod-blackops.org/forum/5-8477-3#28827/
    http://trnavaobfz.sk/predstavujeme-ucastnikov-viii-ligy-select/?unapproved=4476&moderation-hash=6a3e20cf0d2c9ccc8a08007608dd8ac1#comment-4476
    http://chinatn.gotoip1.com/space-uid-142551.html
    http://www.meencantaelcafe.com/lugares/oui-oui-un-cafe-frances-en-buenos-aires/?unapproved=5458&moderation-hash=4d8615cab9bccc2232ebce248901eebc#comment-5458
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message795746/?result=reply#message795746
    http://mybbcode.pl/showthread.php?tid=2&pid=30#pid30
    http://youdoenglish.ru/posts/7594-analytics-usa-business-fresh-news-nef6-com.html
    http://haleem365.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=28&t=37048
    http://ngoinhachung.net/diendan/space-uid-568718.html
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message776004/?result=reply#message776004
    http://blog.redtube.com/2011/04/pornstar-katie-morgan-is-back-on-the-blog/dsc_0229/comment-page-332/#comment-5269399
    http://forum.remmont.com/terrorists-seized-a-five-star-hotel-in-the-capital-of-kenya/#comment/
    http://www.bets10analiz.net/casino-metropol/?unapproved=7806&moderation-hash=7ec8f5e3cdb49641dbaaf1ac342432b2#comment-7806
    tampa.remmont.com/wp-admin/profile.php
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message781327/?result=reply#message781327
    http://blog.gaydar.net/new-year-weve-given-gaydar-fresh-new-look/?unapproved=1425&moderation-hash=743c2b9172f5e360061b0ced98f3ed49#comment-1425
    http://greenpointnews.com/2013/02/07/greenpoint-y-kicks-off-strong-kids-2013/?unapproved=275170&moderation-hash=deee1c7cf07e3b5274cb79ebf816daa1#comment-275170
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799007/
    http://www.cityup.org/bbs/space-uid-267050.html
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message756155/?result=reply#message756155
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799362/
    http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message783196/?result=reply#message783196
    http://0.000000www.shumo.com/forum/home.php?mod=space&uid=420765
    http://debian.ru/members/138331-REMONTwesy
    http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798565/
    http://www.doingtherightthing.nl/forums/users/monicadex/
    http://resource.qualitiasoft.com/blog/best-automation-testing-tool/?unapproved=2077&moderation-hash=df30eeede9beb01acde5d4af50e76f84#comment-2077
    http://www.piattifacili.com/wordpress/wp-admin/index.php?replycontent=%5BIMG%5Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fremmont.com%2Fdemotivator%2F3235.jpg+border%3D10+height%3D240+width%3D240%5B%2FIMG%5D+%0D%0A+%0D%0A%D0%A3%D1%87%D0%B5%D0%BD%D1%8B%D0%B9+%D0%BC%D0%BE%D0%B6%D0%B5%D1%82+%D0%BF%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%BC%D0%B0%D1%82%D1%8C+%D0%BD%D0%B5%D0%B2%D0%B5%D0%B6%D0%B4%D1%83%2C+%D0%BF%D0%BE%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BC%D1%83+%D1%87%D1%82%D0%BE+%D0%BE%D0%BD+%D1%81%D0%B0%D0%BC+%D0%B1%D1%8B%D0%BB+%D1%82%D0%B0%D0%BA%D0%B8%D0%BC+%D0%B2+%D0%B4%D0%B5%D1%82%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B2%D0%B5%2C+%D0%BD%D0%B5%D0%B2%D0%B5%D0%B6%D0%B4%D0%B0+%D0%B6%D0%B5+%D0%BD%D0%B5+%D0%BC%D0%BE%D0%B6%D0%B5%D1%82+%D0%BF%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%BC%D0%B0%D1%82%D1%8C+%D1%83%D1%87%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%BE%2C+%D0%B8%D0%B1%D0%BE+%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%B4%D0%B0+%D1%82%D0%B0%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2%D1%8B%D0%BC+%D0%BD%D0%B5+%D0%B1%D1%8B%D0%BB.+%28%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fmobile.remmont.com%2Flogin-to-elead-log-in-elead-crm-login%2F%5D+elead+crm+mobile+%5B%2Furl%5D+%2C%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fpharma.nef2.com%2Fcreating-a-mortar-bed-for-a-shower-installation-using-sakrete-sand-mix-shower-floor-installation-concrete%2F%5D+sakrete+sand+mix+for+shower+pan+%5B%2Furl%5D+%2C%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fnef6.com%2Fapply-bpi-bdo-auto-loan-use-our-car-financing-calculator-short-term-personal-loans%2F%5D+bpi+auto+loan+calculator+brand+new+%5B%2Furl%5D%29+Siapa+boleh+bagi+contoh+PROPOSAL+%0D%0A%D0%A5%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BE%D1%88%D0%B8%D0%B9+%D0%B4%D1%80%D1%83%D0%B3+%D0%B4%D0%BE%D0%BB%D0%B6%D0%B5%D0%BD+%D0%BD%D0%B0+%D0%B2%D0%B5%D1%81%D0%B5%D0%BB%D0%B8%D0%B5+%D1%8F%D0%B2%D0%BB%D1%8F%D1%82%D1%8C%D1%81%D1%8F+%D0%BF%D0%BE+%D0%B7%D0%BE%D0%B2%D1%83%2C+%D0%BD%D0%B0+%D0%B1%D0%B5%D0%B4%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B5+%D0%B6%D0%B5+%D0%B4%D1%80%D1%83%D0%B3%D0%B0+%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B8%D1%85%D0%BE%D0%B4%D0%B8%D1%82%D1%8C+%D0%B1%D0%B5%D0%B7+%D0%B7%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B0.+%28%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Ffinance.remmont.com%2Ftag%2Ffowlers%2F%5D+fowlers+suzuki+parts+%5B%2Furl%5D+%2C%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fpakistan.nef2.com%2Fsecurity-information-and-event-management-siem-software-reviews-solarwinds-vs-splunk%2F%5D+logpoint+vs+splunk+%5B%2Furl%5D+%2C%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fmauritius.nef6.com%2F2017%2F09%2F07%2Fnau-rn-to-bsn-nau-rn-to-bsn%2F%5D+nau+absn+%5B%2Furl%5D%29+Pedang+Samurai+Katana+%0D%0A%D0%9D%D0%B8%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%B4%D0%B0+%D0%BD%D0%B5+%D0%BF%D0%BE%D0%B7%D0%B4%D0%BD%D0%BE+%D0%BF%D0%BE%D1%83%D0%BC%D0%BD%D0%B5%D1%82%D1%8C.+%28%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Freply.remmont.com%2Fmadura-english-sinhala-dictionary-free-download-and-software-reviews-cnet-thank-you-for-your-reply-email%2F%5D+online+madura+sinhala+english+dictionary+%5B%2Furl%5D+%2C%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fincom.nef2.com%2Fturbotax-2016-2017-tax-return-software-income-elasticity-of-demand%2F%5D+turbotax+freedom+project+%5B%2Furl%5D+%2C%5Burl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fseattle.nef6.com%2F2018%2F06%2F07%2Fforeign-exchange-fx-markets-currency-trading-asb-currency-trading-markets-currency-trading-markets%2F%5D+asb+currency+exchange+rates+%5B%2Furl%5D%29+KAHWIN+LARI+THAILAND+NIKAH+SIAM+URUSAN+POLIGAMI+KHIDMAT+WALI+THAI+%0D%0A&newcomment_author=SABRINADreby&newcomment_author_email=ide.as.inter.i.orsd.esign.s%40gmail.com&newcomment_author_url=http%3A%2F%2Fengland.remmont.com&action=&comment_ID=&comment_post_ID=&status=&position=-1&checkbox=0&mode=dashboard&_ajax_nonce-replyto-comment=77dfb6ffb0
    http://laboruniontv.org/internet-freedom-sb822-passes-california-assembly/#comment-372261/
    http://snyderbusinesslaw.com/trademarking-trump-lessons-white-house/?unapproved=19673&moderation-hash=507708674c184d09d03c944f0438d4ed#comment-19673
    http://bbs.zgmj.gov.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=229155
    http://yukikax.com/index.php
    [/b]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *